Citizens Commission on Human Rights

The Mental Health Watchdog

Australian National Office

The New Queensland Mental Health Draft Bills Will Allow For Children Of Any Age To Consent To Electroshock & Psychosurgery Without Parental Consent

Forced drugging, restraints & seclusion of children without the need for parental consent is set to remain legal.

Please Urgently Take Action

A sad boy looking out through a window.The Queensland Mental Health Act has been under review since mid-2013. There are 2 draft bills (the Government’s and the Opposition’s). Both are on Parliament’s agenda for deciding which one will be used and could be voted into law in late February 2016. Both bills are the same or similar in key areas, it is not known which bill will become the final one. Below are areas of grave concern which need to be changed in both bills:

Click here to download the summary

ELECTROSHOCK OF CHILDREN (ECT): ECT is the brutal application of hundreds of volts of electricity to the head, potentially causing brain damage, memory loss and sometimes death. The World Health Organisation stated, “There are no indications for the use of ECT on minors, and hence this should be prohibited through legislation.” Sicily banned ECT completely in October 2013. Western Australia recently banned the use of ECT on children under 14 and ACT bans ECT for under 12 year olds on 1 March 2016.

In both draft bills, any child (under 18 and voluntarily admitted) considered to have the “capacity to consent,” can consent to ECT and the psychiatrist then applies to the Mental Health Review Tribunal (MHRT) for final approval. No parental consent is needed at any stage. ECT can also be given to involuntarily detained children of any age, if a psychiatrist applies to the MHRT for consent to perform ECT – again no parental consent is needed. The new bills also allow for the use of “emergency electroshock” on children. In 2014/15, Medicare funded 9,911 electroshocks in Qld (the highest in Australia) up from 6,642 in 2009/10, a staggering 49% increase. 126 “emergency electroshocks” were given in 2013/14. Electroshock must be made illegal for use on children, pregnant women and the elderly immediately. It should never be given to involuntary patients without their fully informed consent. [p.52,192,354,355 of Government’s Mental Health Bill 2015 (GMHB) & p.49,170,171,318,319,320 of Opposition’s Mental Health Recovery Model Bill (OMHRMB)]

PSYCHOSURGERY OF CHILDREN: All forms of psychosurgery are correctly banned in NSW and the NT for all age groups. SA and WA have banned all forms for children under 16. It is proposed to ban the forms of psychosurgery involving cutting and burning the brain in Qld in both draft bills, but to allow deep brain stimulation (DBS) psychosurgery for all ages. In DBS, a hole is drilled into the head to implant electrodes through which an electrical current surges from a pacemaker like device inserted under the skin in the chest. DBS can cause irreversible brain damage, seizures, memory loss, suicide and post-operative death. DBS is NOT an approved mental health treatment in Australia.

In 2014, NSW Ministry of Health commissioned the Sax Institute to investigate the clinical efficacy of DBS. The conclusion of this investigation was: “There is insufficient evidence at this point in time to support the use of DBS as a clinical treatment for any psychiatric disorder.” Consequently all forms of psychosurgery remained banned in NSW. It is proposed in both draft bills that if a child is considered to have the “capacity to consent,” parental consent is not needed at any stage including at a Tribunal who gives the final approval for DBS. It is also proposed to re-name psychosurgery-DBS as a “neurosurgical procedure.” They are not the same and this is an attempt to hide the true nature of this experimental practice. Neurosurgery is an operation to rectify a scientifically diagnosed medical condition. Psychosurgery-DBS is performed to change behaviour and the psychiatric diagnosis that leads to the psychosurgery is not based on any scientific test. Psychosurgery must not be re-named as a “neurosurgical procedure.” All psychosurgery disguised as a “neurosurgical procedure” including deep brain stimulation must be completely banned. [p.52,190,193,355,356 of GMHB & p.49,172,321,322 of OMHRMB]

CHILDREN PLACED IN PSYCHIATRIC WARDS WITH ADULTS AND SEXUAL ABUSE: Both draft bills do not rule out children being held in wards with adults. Both draft bills also retain the ability for involuntarily detained children to be strip-searched. Additionally there is no mandatory reporting of sexual abuse or criminal fines in place to ensure reporting of alleged sexual assault of patients by a mental health worker or another patient. The law must be amended to ensure that children are not placed in adult wards and to ensure mandatory reporting of alleged sexual abuse to police. [p.45,46,289,291,292,296,297 of GMHB & p.43,44,261,263,264,268,269 of OMHRMB]

CRIMINAL FINES AND PRISON TERMS FOR HARM CAUSED BY PSYCHIATRIC TREATMENT: Criminal fines and prison terms are only $11,780 (100 penalty units*) or 1 year imprisonment for performing electroshock and deep brain stimulation outside the law in the Opposition’s draft bill. Ill-treatment of a patient carries the same penalty. The Government’s new draft bill has doubled the Opposition’s fines and prison terms. In comparison the Qld Animal Care and Protection Act, has a fine of $235,600 (2,000 penalty units*) or 3 years imprisonment for causing pain to, abusing, terrifying or worrying an animal. All criminal fines and imprisonment terms must be increased in any new bill. [p.170,172,376, of OMHRMB & p.191,193,415 of GMHB] * As of 1 July 2015 one penalty unit is $117.80.

CAPACITY TO CONSENT: In both draft bills, for someone to be considered to have the “capacity to consent” to psychiatric treatment, they must recognise/understand they are “mentally ill.” If they disagree they are mentally ill, they are considered not to have the capacity to consent and could be involuntarily detained. A diagnosis is based on “checklists” and arbitrary opinions of psychiatrists. The main psychiatric manual used in Australia to diagnose psychiatric disorders itself states for example, that there are no laboratory tests for ADHD or Schizophrenia. Medical studies prove that undiagnosed physical conditions can manifest as psychiatric symptoms and this clause will lead to even more people correctly saying they are not mentally ill and subsequently being forcibly drugged and treated for something they do not have. In Oct 2015, it was reported to the Health and Ambulance Services Parliamentary Committee that a person died from a ruptured spleen after somebody made the mistaken diagnosis of “delusional shoulder pain”. Involuntary treatment must not occur just because a person does not recognise they are mentally ill. Full physical tests must be done to determine if their “psychiatric symptoms” are caused by an undiagnosed physical condition. [p.52 of GMHB & p.49 of OMHRMB, Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSMIV) p.88,305]

ACCOUNTABILITY FOR MONEY SPENT: The Qld mental health budget has exploded 42% since 2009/10, up from $809,996,000 to $1,152,117,000 in 2014/15. Yet there has been a 65% increase in mental health service complaints between 2009/10 and 2011/12. If the funds spent were actually helping people this would be evidenced by decreasing numbers of complaints and people labelled as “mentally ill.”

ALTERNATIVES: There is no doubt that some children who are troubled require special care. But they should be given holistic, humane care that improves their condition. Institutions should be safe havens where children and adults voluntarily seek help for themselves or their child without fear of indefinite incarceration or harmful and terrifying treatment. They need a quiet and safe environment, good nutrition, rest, exercise and help with life’s problems. Extensive medical evidence proves that underlying and undiagnosed physical illnesses can manifest as psychiatric symptoms and therefore should be addressed with the correct medical treatment, not psychiatric techniques. With proper medical treatment and real help people can lead healthier, happier lives.


Please write, fax, email your objections to the below Members of Parliament including:

Premier: Hon Annastacia Palaszuk, PO Box 15185, City East, QLD 4002 Tel: 07 3719 7000 Fax: 07 37372109 Email:

Leader of Opposition: Mr Lawrence Springborg, PO Box 15057, City East, QLD 4002 Tel: 07 38386767 Fax: 07 30128004 Email:

Minister for Health: Hon Cameron Dick, GPO Box 48, Brisbane, QLD 4001 Tel: 07 3035 6100 Fax 07 34454109 Email:

Shadow Minister for Health: Mr Mark McArdle, PO Box 3998, Caloundra QLD 4551 Tel: 07 53294100 Fax: 07 53294109

Members of Parliament contacts:¬bers/current/list

Both the “Government’s” Qld Mental Health Bill 2015 and the “Opposition’s” Mental Health (Recovery Model) Bill 2015 can be downloaded at: tees/HASC/inquiries/current-inquiries/B1-MH-RM-B2015

For more information or copies of this summary, contact the Citizens Committee on Human Rights (CCHR) Australian National Office:
TEL: 02 99649844

© 2015 CCHR. CCHR was established in 1969 by the Church of Scientology and the late Professor of Psychiatry, Dr Thomas Szasz, to investigate and expose psychiatric violations of human rights.

Tagged under